5 Signs A Leader On Your Team Needs Executive Coaching

If you’re a CEO or a VP of HR, you can usually spot an executive coaching candidate before they realize it for themselves. From your vantage point, you get to see things that may be invisible to the executive living inside their own day-to-day world, like attrition patterns, succession bench depth, who’s getting promoted on other teams and who’s carrying more workload than they should be.

The hard part isn’t seeing the signs. Rather, it’s knowing when the signs add up to a candidate for executive leadership coaching compared with a training problem, a performance problem or just a leader having a rough quarter.  These signs have a few things in common: They’re observable from where you sit; They tend to resist the usual leadership development tools, like 360s, leadership courses and books from the airport bookstore; They resist those tools because the gap that justifies coaching isn’t a knowledge gap; it’s the leader’s behavior under pressure.

Here are five signs that the leader you have in mind is genuinely an executive coaching candidate.

They’re Tolerating A Low Performer Everyone Else Can See.  When a leader covers for a known weak performer, it destroys the leader’s credibility and makes it politically impossible to hold anyone else accountable.

Their High Performers Are Burning Out Or Quitting.  This is the first sign HR tends to notice, because it shows up in the data you’re already tracking. You’ve got A-players leaving the team, engagement scores in that area are dropping, and stay interviews surface frustration about workload imbalance. Exit interviews are vague, with lots of “personal reasons” and “new opportunity” language.

Nobody On Their Team Gets Promoted.  Look at the leader’s direct reports over the past two or three years. How many have moved up? Not laterally, not into adjacent roles on someone else’s team, but genuinely promoted into bigger executive roles. For the leader you have in mind, the honest answer is often zero or close to it.

They Get Defensive When Challenged.  This is the sign that shows up most clearly when the leader gets feedback. Imagine that a leader has just gone through a 360 assessment or you’re analyzing open-ended responses to an engagement survey. You read the comments and you see phrases like “doesn’t take feedback well,” “hard to give bad news to,” “argues when challenged,” or the polite version, which is usually “passionate about being right.” This is clearly a leader that doesn’t respond well to getting challenged.

Their Team Is Afraid To Tell Them The Truth.  Bad news arrives late to this leader, and they get surprised by something their team knew about for three weeks. Direct reports rehearse before going into their office, and staff meetings are oddly quiet, with one or two people doing most of the talking. Their engagement survey usually shows decent “satisfaction with my manager” scores but low scores on psychological safety, which is a reliable tell that people are reporting what seems safe to report.

show less